← Back to journal

The People Who Love Your Business Are the Worst People to Ask How to Grow It

Dream Outcome · JournalFig. THE-PE

The People Who Love Your Business Are the Worst People to Ask How to Grow It

You ran a customer survey last quarter. The results came back glowing. Net Promoter Score through the roof. Testimonials you could frame on the wall. "Great service." "Always recommend you." "Would never go anywhere else."

You built your next campaign around those words. Updated the landing page. Wrote new ad copy. Felt confident.

Then growth stalled. Leads plateaued. The phone didn't ring more often. Nothing changed.

Here's the uncomfortable reason: you built your entire marketing strategy on feedback from the 20% of the market that already chose you. The other 80% never got a vote. And the other 80% is where every dollar of growth lives.

Your Feedback Loop Has a Hole in It

Most businesses collect customer feedback the same way. They email their database. They survey recent buyers. They read Google reviews. They ask happy clients for testimonials.

Every one of those methods has the same blind spot: they only capture the voice of people who already said yes.

Sam Tomlinson calls this the Echo Chamber Trap: "If your customer research only makes you feel good, you're doing it wrong." The problem isn't that your customers are lying. They genuinely love you. The problem is that their experience tells you nothing about the vastly larger group of people who have never heard of you, looked at you once and moved on, or chose your competitor instead.

The data on just how biased this feedback is should make you uncomfortable. Forrester research found that post-journey NPS surveys systematically overstate loyalty because they only include customers who completed their journey. Average survey response rates have dropped to 6.1% in 2026, down from 13.4% in 2022. The people who respond are your loudest fans and your angriest detractors. The silent majority in between? Gone.

In non-anonymous environments, respondents inflate satisfaction scores by 10-15% just to avoid awkwardness. You're not measuring loyalty. You're measuring politeness.

What you're measuringWhat you think it tells youWhat it actually tells you
NPS from existing customersHow the market sees youHow your fans see you
Google review averageYour reputationThe opinion of people motivated enough to write
Testimonial requestsYour strongest value propsWhat loyal buyers say to justify their own decision
Customer survey resultsMarket sentimentThe views of 6% of your happiest customers

The result is a marketing strategy calibrated perfectly for people who were going to buy anyway. Meanwhile, the people you actually need to reach are seeing messaging that wasn't built for them.

The Science Says Growth Lives Outside Your Customer Base

Byron Sharp's research at the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute across 60 years of consumer panel data demolishes the idea that growth comes from your existing customers.

The numbers are stark. Light buyers and non-buyers make up 70-80% of any brand's customer base. For a large brand in a high-frequency category, Trinh, Dawes and Sharp's 2023 research found that 31% of sales potential sits in current non-buyers, 52% in light buyers, and only 17% in heavy buyers. That's 83% of your growth opportunity sitting in people your feedback loop never touches.

Bain & Company's 2024 analysis of over 4,000 brands confirmed it: penetration growth accounts for the majority of revenue growth across nearly every category. Purchase frequency barely moves.

Sharp puts it bluntly: "Brands don't grow because people love them. They grow because people remember them."

This connects directly to something we've explored before: why your loyal customers won't grow your business. The Double Jeopardy Law shows that loyalty is mostly a function of brand size. It rises as you grow. It doesn't cause growth.

Yet the entire feedback infrastructure of most SMEs is pointed squarely at the heavy buyers who contribute 17% of future growth, while ignoring the 83% that determines whether the business actually scales.

Confirmation Bias Is Your Default Setting

This isn't just a structural problem. It's a psychological one.

Daniel Kahneman's research on confirmation bias shows that humans instinctively seek out information that supports what they already believe. We don't do this deliberately. It's a feature of System 1 thinking, the fast, automatic processing that handles most of our decisions.

When a business owner reads five glowing reviews and one critical one, System 1 does the work. The positive reviews confirm the narrative: we're doing great. The negative review gets rationalised: that customer was difficult, it was an edge case, they didn't understand what we offer.

A McKinsey study of more than 1,000 major business investments found that organisations that actively worked to reduce cognitive bias in their decision-making achieved returns up to seven percentage points higher. Seven points. Just from making better decisions with the same information.

The echo chamber in customer research is confirmation bias at scale. You're not just seeking confirming evidence. You've built an entire system that can only produce confirming evidence. And then you're making strategic decisions based on it.

Kahneman's advice for countering this: "Put rules in place that must be followed." Don't rely on willpower to seek disconfirming information. Build the process so you can't avoid it.

The Three Audiences Your Marketing Strategy Actually Needs

Tomlinson's framework cuts through the noise. There are three groups you need to hear from, and most businesses only talk to one.

1. Customers Who Love You

Yes, talk to them. But not for validation. You're looking for language. How do they describe the problem you solve? What words do they use? What was the moment they decided to buy? What almost stopped them?

This is where your best ad copy lives. Not in your marketing team's brainstorm. In the actual words your customers use to describe their experience.

2. People Who Rejected You

This is where it gets uncomfortable. These are the people who visited your site, maybe even filled out a form, but never converted. Or they bought once and never came back.

What happened? What was the gap between what they needed and what you offered? This group tells you what's broken. And broken things are often the highest-leverage fixes available.

3. Your Ideal Customer Who Doesn't Know You Exist

This is the group most businesses completely ignore. These are people who fit your target profile but have never heard of you. They have no preconceptions. They're not on your list.

What this group gives you is invaluable: an unbiased view of the market. What do they think about the problem you solve? What solutions are they currently using? What language do they use to describe their needs? Not your language. Theirs.

When you combine insights from all three, you get a complete picture. The lovers tell you what's working. The rejectors tell you what's broken. The unaware tell you how the market actually thinks.

AudienceWhat they tell youHow to reach themWhat changes
Customers who love youThe language that resonatesEmail, phone, post-purchase surveysYour ad copy and messaging
People who rejected youThe objections you're not addressingExit surveys, sales follow-up, lost-deal interviewsYour landing pages and offer
People who don't know youHow the market actually thinks about the problemLinkedIn outreach, market research, industry forumsYour positioning and targeting

Why This Matters More Than Your Ad Account

Les Binet and Peter Field's analysis of 996 campaigns in the IPA Effectiveness Awards databank provides the effectiveness data that ties this together.

Of campaigns in the IPA database that achieved growth, 22% grew through penetration strategies compared to just 7% through loyalty strategies. Penetration campaigns were nearly three times as effective as loyalty campaigns across the average number of business effects.

This isn't a minor edge. It's a 3:1 ratio in favour of strategies designed to reach new buyers.

But here's the connection most people miss: if your customer research only captures the voice of existing buyers, your messaging will be calibrated for loyalty, not penetration. You'll write ads that resonate with people who already chose you. You'll build landing pages that address objections your current customers overcame years ago. You'll position against competitors your fans already rejected.

Meanwhile, the 95% of the market that isn't currently buying from you hears messaging built for someone else's experience. As Ehrenberg-Bass research found, up to 95% of B2B buyers are not in market for your product at any given time. When they do enter the market, your brand needs to be easy to think of and easy to buy. That requires messaging shaped by how the market thinks, not how your fans think.

This is why your marketing works in quarters but your customers think in years. The brand-building work that reaches non-buyers today pays off when they enter the market months or years from now. But only if the message was built for them in the first place.

How to Ask Better Questions (And Why "Why" Is the Wrong One)

Even when businesses do talk to the right people, they often ask the wrong questions.

Tomlinson's key insight: don't lead with "why." "Why did you buy?" puts people on the defensive. It forces post-hoc rationalisation. You get a tidy story, not the messy truth.

Instead, lead with open-ended questions that invite stories:

That last question is the single most valuable question in customer research. The objections your customers overcame are the same objections your prospects are struggling with right now. And if you've never asked it, your marketing might be getting people to the form while the form talks them out of it.

When people tell stories, they reveal details they'd never mention in response to a direct question. They tell you about the moment of frustration that triggered their search. They mention the competitor they almost chose and why. They use the exact language they use in their own heads to describe their problems.

That language, their words, not yours, is the raw material for messaging that cuts through. When your ad copy sounds like something your prospect would say to a colleague, it resonates. When it sounds like something a marketer approved through three rounds of committee review, it doesn't.

What This Means for Your Business

You don't need a six-figure research programme. You need a deliberate shift in who you listen to.

Start with five conversations. Not surveys. Conversations. One with a loyal customer (for language). Two with people who enquired but didn't convert (for objections). Two with people in your target market who've never heard of you (for positioning). Record everything. With permission. The specific words people use are worth more than any summary. A 30-second clip of a prospect explaining why they chose your competitor will change your marketing faster than a month of dashboard reviews. Look for the language gap. Compare how your existing customers describe what you do versus how the market describes the problem. The gap between those two vocabularies is exactly where your messaging is failing. Build it into your process. Kahneman's research is clear: you can't rely on good intentions to overcome confirmation bias. Build the system so disconfirming evidence reaches you automatically. Monthly lost-deal reviews. Quarterly market conversations. Annual competitor-customer interviews.

The people who love your business are telling you how to keep them. That's useful, but it's a maintenance strategy. The people who've never heard of you, or who looked and walked away, are telling you how to grow.

Most businesses are only listening to one of those groups. The growth is in the other two.

Further Reading


Dream Outcome is an Australian digital marketing agency helping SMEs grow through Google Ads, Facebook Ads, and Email Marketing.
Book a free call

Ready to grow profitably?

Get a free digital marketing plan tailored to your business. No lock-in, no long commitments.

Book my free call  →